Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by geogra4 2128 days ago
Wonder if hockey will either go the way of Tennis (where technology has rapidly changed how the game has been played) or baseballe - where the bats are always wood.
6 comments

Hockey seems to be constantly evolving both its technologies and its rules.

As an example of this (other than the new sticks being tested in the article), prior to the pandemic the NHL was set to introduce a new puck for the playoffs that would "will transmit data 60 times per second, including location, speed, acceleration and deceleration and distance travelled." There's similar tech ready to be rolled out for jerseys. The end goal being for advanced analytics to be able to map how fast everything is going and how the game moves, as well as to possibly aid in goal review (which is difficult with the shape of a puck, unlike say soccer/football with its round ball). They tested it at the All-Star game and teams have been practicing with it, but the league decided to hold off on it to reduce the potential point of failures during their return to play.

Source: https://www.tsn.ca/nhl-s-new-puck-will-premiere-on-opening-n...

All that's lacking is augmenting the broadcast with a blue halo and a trail, and it's deja-vu all over again:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FoxTrax

They probably chose 60Hz to match the broadcast framerate, but that doesn't seem fast enough to be accurate after fast collisions.
location and speed at the same time? now THAT is interesting..
Jokes aside, that must be a serious problem in a game where they hit the puck with a wooden planck.
Let's hope that hockey doesn't go exactly the way of baseball.

If you haven't noticed, pro baseball players have mostly switched from ash to maple. Maple bats now fail more often and they fail catastrophically, with sharp fragments flying at high speed. Players and fans are getting injured far more frequently, such as a Cubs player getting impaled [1].

At least baseball is starting to catch up with hockey in terms of nets that prevent objects flying into the fan areas.

[1] https://bats.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/09/20/cubs-bizarre-injur...

> Cubs rookie Tyler Colvin remains in the hospital Sunday night after a shard of teammate Welington Castillo’s maple bat punctured his chest during Chicago’s game against the Marlins. Colvin was on third base when Castillo broke his bat on a double down the left-field line. A larger piece of Castillo’s bat hit Colvin in the chest, with a sharp edge piercing his chest wall.

> Colvin is in stable condition at Jackson Memorial Hospital in Miami. There was minimal bleeding, but doctors were trying to prevent a collapsed lung, according to MLB.com. If Colvin had been hit or cut in the neck, his injury could have been much more severe.

Hockey has already adopted revolutionary technology many times. Consider composite skate blade holders replacing steel blade holders, synthetic materials in protective equipment replacing leather, deer hair, and felt, aluminum and various sorts of composite and carbon fiber sticks replacing wooden hockey stick shafts, and so on.

I am a retired college hockey player who transitioned to officiating at the NCAA level.

I don’t think they should or ever will step away from wood bats. It’s one of the few things that levels the playing field for all batters; instead letting brute force be the power behind the contact.

Aluminum and corked bats would ultimately give an unfair advantage to the user as compared to a wood slugger. It’s fine in minor league and collegiate sports as they do not follow the MLB’s stricter regulations but if they plan to aim for the major leagues, they should start training with wood.

On second thought, I think the only time there would be a change is if there were a noticeable impact on the environment and the amount of word being cut to produce bats. But since America’s trademark sport is baseball, I do not see this happening any time soon.

Aluminum and corked bats also become a player safety issue in the majors. It's already a problem at all levels honestly, but the balance would be far more dangerous increasing already high major league exit velocities.
BBCOR has solved this problem with metal bats; their COR is identical to wood bats (and likely worse in the aggregate).
Wood products harvested sustainably protect forest lands by increasing their economic viability. If forests lose economic value from timber, they are more likely to be clearcut for agriculture.

Edit: maple is also one of the most prevalent commercial timbers in USA, is native in most parts of the country and bat usage is so small a percent of maple consumption as to be effectively 0.

I think the rules of the game have more affect on how skaters play ice hockey than the equipment. Look at all the rule changes coming out of the lockout just to defeat the trap. The trap still would've been the problem it was if these sticks were around 15+ years ago.
I never understood why baseball doesn't just go all out aluminum. Make the stadiums bigger, put more players on the field, whatever...