Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Press2forEN 2137 days ago
The reaction to his election traumatized me. For the first time in my life I felt like a foreigner in my own country.

I disagree with most of his policy positions. His tax cut was too small, his insistence on opening the public schools is baffling to me given how the public school system manufactures his opposition. He was never able to build the wall, although I expected that. Ultimately I can work with my disagreements with him and the right more broadly. There is room for compromise there.

But watching the left since 2016 and especially recently after the death of George Floyd, policy matters don't concern me much anymore. I'm afraid of the left. I feel intimidated by their vast cultural and social power. And I'm going to vote for someone that unapologetically opposes them.

I know that doesn't really answer your question as you asked it. But there it is anyway.

3 comments

The police murdered an American citizen, without trial, on camera, and you're going to oppose the... opposition of that?
Not just murdered. He held his knee on a mans neck for eight minutes and forty six seconds! He held it on there for minutes after he became unconscious and other people yelled at him to stop! There is no excuse.
I think it's perfectly valid to be horrified at the Floyd murder _and_ the response.
What I've noticed about your reply is that you didn't actually mention a policy achievement but a reaction to a perceived change in the country. It doesn't sound like your life is better. It sounds like you're worried about dramatic change even though the last four years has been tumultuous.

If that's the case, why do you want to vote for four more years of that?

More questions:

Why are you afraid of the left? What outcomes are you afraid of in particular?

The Trump administration has deployed federal forces to states that have not requested asked for any help. Do you believe this is necessary? And if so, why? Do you worry what precedents this sets for the left should Democrats take the Senate and White House?

What do you think about DeJoy's decision to functionally slow the speed of the Post Office?

How do you find Trump's handling of the coronavirus in comparison to leaders in Europe and Asia?

How do you think four more years of Trump will improve your life?

Re: Covid handling as opined at https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-biden-bait-and-switch-11596...

"Media coverage of the nation’s standing would change dramatically after a Biden victory, even if the reality does not. Mr. Biden promises increased federal coronavirus spending, but as president he couldn’t override governors’ authority to restrict economic activity, and he doesn’t propose to alter Mr. Trump’s program to accelerate vaccine and treatment development. With Mr. Trump embracing masks and trillions in federal spending, and high case totals in blue California and red Florida alike, a Biden victory wouldn’t change the epidemic’s trajectory. Yet, as the media hailed Gov. Andrew Cuomo despite his disastrous policy of transferring coronavirus patients into nursing homes and New York’s record high deaths, Mr. Biden’s election would also miraculously transform the virus from an existential threat into a manageable hindrance."

I'll bite! You get a screed! I'll address every question you raised...

> If that's the case, why do you want to vote for four more years of that?

Tumultuous does not imply worse. A high variance process can have zero mean.

> Why are you afraid of the left?

The Constitution was designed to handle an attack by disperse interests. It was not designed to handle a coordinated assault on the executive and the simultaneous watering down of the judiciary (e.g. court packing). Ten years ago I could say stupid things in public without being afraid for my livelihood. Now, I worry when I will cancelled for speaking aloud what I believe will help my fellow citizens. This is wrong and wholly attributable to the left. I can say progressive things around right-leaning friends. I dare not more than suggest non-orthodoxy around my left-leaning ones.

> What outcomes are you afraid of in particular?

That the notion of equality under the law is lost for the notion of absolute equality (i.e. interpreting the Declaration's "created equal" for instantaneous equality as defined by the mob du jour). That an increasing number of my personally earned dollars will be confiscated to support ends with which I disagree. For example, the Fed has no business addressing inequality as suggested by the Biden platform. Those poor bastards have enough trouble with monetary policy as we've agreed upon it for the past several decades.

> The Trump administration has deployed federal forces to states that have not requested asked for any help. Do you believe this is necessary?

Yes.

> And if so, why?

By what right does a state government decide to allow the destruction of Federal property? The Federal government serves the interests of the other 49 states when it shows up in 1 to address civil disorder. Did the other 49 states all say that they wanted the Federal government to turn a blind eye? We're all in this nation together.

> Do you worry what precedents this sets for the left should Democrats take the Senate and White House?

Absolutely. All unconstitutional concentrations of power in the legislative, executive, or the judiciary undermine the the dispersion of power aimed for by the Founders. Prior to Trump, Obama had a field day with executive actions. Both should be hung out to dry for what they did. Both allowed the legislators to avoid hard choices and instead ruled by dictat. When the executive steps in, it allows the legislative to skirt their jobs. We elect those asshats to make choices, not point fingers and make speeches.

> What do you think about DeJoy's decision to functionally slow the speed of the Post Office?

The legislative branch can do what it wants to the USPS. Let the legislative branch sort it out. In particular, if the House is unhappy let the House put forward legislation in the manner that Congress should pass all laws as set forth under the Constitution. Let the elected members of the Senate suffer the brunt of their constituents if those constituents do not like how the Senate votes on the House's proposal. It's a great system so rely on it.

> How do you find Trump's handling of the coronavirus in comparison to leaders in Europe and Asia?

See the peer comment. Generally, fine as evidenced by https://www.statista.com/statistics/1104709/coronavirus-deat.... There is a lot of fearmongering and virtue-signaling baked into the Covid response commentary. I believe kneecapping the economy in the short term is the wrong choice in the long term.

> How do you think four more years of Trump will improve your life?

The past four years has improved my quality of life vs what I suspect would have been the alternative. The economy was humming (humming!) prior to Covid appearing. Imagine the current economic situation had unemployment been even what Obama left when he exited office. Most of my improvements have been because, as a generally free economic agent, I have invested in myself instead of asking for a third party to hand me things.

The Trump tax cuts have been beneficial to many, and the capping of SALT deductions ensures that some states do not soak the country instead of soaking their own inhabitants when they raise rates.

Just today, De Vos made considerable headway to stop "Dear Colleague" on campus, Iran/Venezuela were taken to task for skirting sanctions, and Israel/UAE announced diplomatic breakthroughs unexpected even a year prior.

As for going forward for four more years, the Constitution was designed to deal with a useless President. Four more years of a high-noise status quo is far less dangerous to America than a coordinated attempt to cast aside what's been inherited and to replace it with a bunch of Bernie/A.O.C. wish lists. Hillary lost because she was too damn conniving in many moderate's eyes. People simply forget how much they owe to the ideas of their forebearers-- the modern world is a consequence of the competition of many competing interests. When we subject the world to the designs of bureaucrats we lose the power of the free market, the greatest force for good that humanity has ever known.

> You didn't ask it but...

...the world isn't as f*cked as reading the New York Times or the Washington Post would have one think. It also certainly isn't as rosy as the WSJ opinion pages would suggest. But, consider, a pandemic is upon us and somehow the social order is not unraveling. We're discussing how, not if, to educate the children. People still plan for decades hence. Private property rights are upheld. Invaders are not on the door step. Pretty much the only thing up for grabs is if the left is going to deep six you for having dared to breathe unorthodox thoughts aloud. They sure do love to destroy their own, no?

I know its late but I'll add:

I'm afraid that the history of my country will be permanently revised and that my children will learn the revised version instead of the patriotic one. I fear I'll have to correct everything they learn about history and language.

I'm afraid that the public school system and the universities will convert my children from happy and productive citizens into angry activists.

I'm afraid that a portion of most products I buy will wind up supporting causes that are detrimental to my own interests, as the left has somehow gained control of the board rooms of major corporations.

I live in a dark blue state under lockdown and I fear we'll never truly be freed from it. I worry that the left will once again dispatch extremists to my neighborhood because of some unpredictable future event that sets them off.

I believe the left hates men, boys, white Americans, and Christians. I'm most of those things and you couldn't induce me to vote for a Democrat even if you paid me FIRE money right now.

I know that only answers your first question. I don't know who DeJoy is. I don't care about the post office. And I don't care about his response to the virus. In my opinion, the government has no role to play in virus handling.

I don't support the president because of his polices. I support him because he opposes the left. The only thing he could do to lose my support is to cave into them.

>But watching the left since 2016 and especially recently after the death of George Floyd, policy matters don't concern me much anymore. I'm afraid of the left. I feel intimidated by their vast cultural and social power. And I'm going to vote for someone that unapologetically opposes them.

I suspect that rioters burning half of Minneapolis down won Minnesota for Trump, after coming within 1.5% of winning the state in 2016. (Yes, the only state that voted for Mondale in 1984.) If he wins all other states he won in 2016, Trump only has to win one of Minnesota, Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin for reelection. Look at how close polls are there already (https://emersonpolling.reportablenews.com/pr/minnesota-2020-... let's see how things look in another month or two, when people are less afraid of being called a racist for vocalizing dislike of violent "protests", even to a pollster.

Don't count out other states, like Oregon and Washington, that saw and are seeing continued violence in the name of Floyd and BLM.