Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by laurentl 2142 days ago
Unless I misunderstand your concept, using your website would entail granting it rights to my AWS account to access billing info and shutdown pretty much any service. So, something close to the Administrator policy. I guess you could do something more granular e.g. stop but not start, specify resources, etc but in any case I need to grant you enough rights to shut down my account, which is the entire premise of your service. What are the chances that I’ll grant this type of access to a 3rd party I don’t know about? Snowball, meet Hell.

Also, I don’t want my production account to be shut down. Notified, sure. But if my spending takes off because Elon Musk tweeted about my website and I’m getting a lot of hits (and hopefully a lot of new paying customers) I definitely do not want my service to go down.

In other words, your idea isn’t for me, but it might well work for side projects where you don’t want to spend too much and don’t care about the service going down. In any case the security aspect is going to be tough to manage properly, and is going to make your service a juicy target for hackers.

1 comments

> Also, I don’t want my production account to be shut down. Notified, sure.

This is already an AWS feature: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AmazonCloudWatch/latest/monitori...