Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by danpalmer 2143 days ago
I think the marketing line of "No new features" could lure people into a false sense of security on this upgrade, even if the breaking changes are minimal.

By all means make breaking changes, just maybe tone down the marketing.

1 comments

How is a very elaborate blog post indicating the what & why considered marketing?

In my opinion this goes WAY beyond the usual changelog entry in other repositories.

Don't get me wrong, this is great documentation, very high quality, and well done to the React team for a great release and what I think is a solid decision around what to include and what not to include in this release.

I think it's important to understand though that React is _marketed_, and unfortunately for many a name as clearly stated as this will likely define their expectations significantly. This could be especially pronounced for those who are less proficient in English.