Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cyphar 2137 days ago
> The speed of light is not an absolute constant as Einstein believed. C just represented the speed that light can travel as a relationship between energy and mass. My favorite form of the equation is C equals the square root of energy divided by mass. Behaviorally all that means is that as the energy to mass ratio goes up, the speed of light goes up. And as the mass to energy ratio goes up, the speed of light goes down. Hence time dilation, black holes, etc.

That isn't what's happening in relativity. That might be a neat trick for you to remember whether an effect is dilation or contraction (though I personally find it more confusing), but the speed of light does not change in different frames of reference -- this is a fundamental property of relativity (and is an assertion by Einstein, who argued that the speed of light derived from Maxwell's equations means that if light functions in all frames of reference it must propagate at the same speed).

And while the mass-energy equivalence equation you mentioned is used in the way you described (rearranging it to have the speed of light as one term), it's actually used explicitly because the value must be constant -- the implication being that mass-energy is an invariant in relativity (though technically this derivation is backwards -- E=mc² is the conclusion you reach after assuming mass-energy conservation).

Relativity is already unintuitive enough, I personally find that adding incorrect-but-seemingly-intuitive explanations probably hurts your understanding more than it helps.