Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by zb 5552 days ago
Because if you're the innocent target of a malicious sign-up then you shouldn't have to take any further action - particularly action that could expose you to further harm, such as clicking on a link randomly emailed to you from some site you've never heard of - to avoid having your email address associated with the account.

Edit: You also shouldn't have to be watching your email like a hawk 24/7 just in case somebody signs you up for something, so that you can stop them from impersonating you before they do any damage.

In short, it's the difference between opt-in and opt-out. Identity theft should almost never be opt-out.

1 comments

More than that - a number of services (for example B2B SaaS) depend on knowing the email identity of their user. Are you John Jones <john.jones@goldmansachs.com>? Of course you are, you signed up with that email address and the system accepted you.

If a system like, say, Woobius, doesn't confirm emails, people will abuse this lack of feature.