[supercanuck]

Sorry I find your suggestions unacceptable because the point of the article, and I think this is the root of your where your misinterpretation stems from, is there is a measurable change in the opinions of those who lost their job. Before they felt like the jobs would come back, now they think they are permanent.

That is a loss in confidence. your alternative titles contain no such information and aren't accurately describing what is happening.

I'm just going to ignore the rest of your analysis because it doesn't seem to be relevant and distracts from the point.

[chrisco255]

The loss of confidence is the story. That is not reflected in the headline. The story is about sentiment. The headline implies a more serious undertone. It's not irrelevant. Clickbait and sensationalism is a big problem these days, if you haven't noticed. In fact, it may lead to the collapse of Western civilization. At least, that's my feelings on the matter anyways.