[kgwgk]

> 2. The approach I'm used to of having negative numbers in the debits and positive credits. This makes all the double accounting balancing much simpler. But I can see it may confuse some people when assets are negative.

So, if people were able to overcome their confusion, would you have balance sheets written like this?

   $ in millions
   
   ASSETS                                        LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY
   
   Cash and Short Term Investments   -133546     Deposits                      117756
   Other Assets                      -859422     Other liabilities             784947
   ------------                      -------     -----------------             ------
   Total Assets                      -992968     Total liabilities             902703

                                                 Shareholders' equity           90265
                                                 ====================          ======
                                                 Total liabilities
                                                 and shareholders' equity      992968

If you really want to change the signs in one of the sides, so instead of getting the same totals they sum to zero, it would make much more sense to do it the other way: keep assets positive and let liabilities be negative (as other commenters have suggested).

   $ in millions
   
   ASSETS                                        LIABILITIES AND SHAREHOLDERS' EQUITY
   
   Cash and Short Term Investments    133546     Deposits                     -117756
   Other Assets                       859422     Other liabilities            -784947
   ------------                       ------     -----------------            -------
   Total Assets                       992968     Total liabilities            -902703

                                                 Shareholders' equity          -90265
                                                 ====================         =======
                                                 Total liabilities
                                                 and shareholders' equity     -992968

But one property of the usual presentation is lost: equity is no longer equal to net assets (which are $90265mn). You would need to change the sign of equity when considering it as an asset.