[em-bee]

what's bonkers is wanting to punish users for something they didn't do. judges not understanding technology strikes again.

[aspaceman]

I believe this decision punishes Twitter - not the users.

[em-bee]

to punish twitter they wouldn't need the identities of the retweeters. the only use for knowing the retweeters is to haul them into court.

[roblabla]

To be fair, they could be asking for the identities in order to summon them as witnesses against twitter. I don't hold much faith that this is the intention though...

[em-bee]

the thought crossed my mind, but wouldn't you do that after you sue in the discovery step?