[fluffy87]

Your claim that “as” being used is incompatible with it being unidiomatic is false.

The docs, the reference, and the RFCs all regards “as” as a mistake that should not be used, and _many_ features have been introduced over the years to reduce the cases in which “as” is the only alternative.

There are cases in which there is currently no alternative, so people “must” use “as”. This does not imply that it is idiomatic to do so.