Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by AsyncAwait 2162 days ago
> independent media

Actually the mainstream TV & newspaper media are overall owned by a very few holding companies and there's plenty of stories of people being subtly or overtly pressured to either change tune or be forced off the air if they ie spoke extensively against the Iraq War pre-invasion.
1 comments
threeseed 2162 days ago
They aren’t directly controlled by the government though.

And you have plenty of organisations like NPR and PBS which are truly independent.

Also anyone can create a news site or blog without worrying about it being blocked.

link
umanwizard 2162 days ago
PBS and NPR are in fact directly controlled by the government. It’s interesting that those are your two examples of gold standard independent media.
link
threeseed 2162 days ago
They are both independent non-profits which rely on a mix of private and public funds.

Not sure through what mechanism you think they are directly controlled.

link
pishpash 2162 days ago
The state-controlled CPB exerts significant influence via funding and the FCC via regulatory reach. This isn't theoretical. Whether that's "direct" control or not is in the eye of the beholder, but people have accused media in other countries of being not independent under similar circumstances.

Personally I think anyone can live in their own fiction as long as they are not hurting anyone else, but to consider a strategic resource like the media as being truly independent in any country is naive. You're literally missing an entire world if you do not look outside your home country.

link
selimthegrim 2162 days ago
No, you’re thinking of VOA and stuff that used to be under erstwhile Broadcasting Board of Governors
link
minerjoe 2162 days ago
> aren't directly controlled

Why control things directly when you don't have to?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Mockingbird

link
AsyncAwait 2161 days ago
> They aren’t directly controlled by the government though.

No. They're controlled by multinational corporations with clear profit motives and conflicts of interests and thus tend to be biased in favor of those industries.

In China you have state dominance so you have state controlled media, in the U.S. you have corporate media. That's not independent media, just the other side of the same coin.

And if your argument is "they don't control the army", the military industrial complex means they don't have to do so directly.

link