| Not the worst approach, and as long as it's in the spirit of cooperation might even be good. UX people could tune or at least comment on the interface, security people could fuzz or pentest the library... however, for a lot of actual problems in actual open source libraries it requires a crapton of internalization -- again, for free. Granted, it's for open source but it could be argued it's even WORSE approach for the company, since they're getting free benefit from expertise and work. Also, I'm a private person, I have splintered online identities, I'm not going to give my 'hobbyist' github account in a professional context, and I'm also certainly not going to make a github account just for interviews and applications. I'm lucky enough to have connections that will probably keep me employed as long as I like, and the tales of interviews and free work that's required to put up just to get a chance seems insane. 4 hours... okay, I can sort of see that, I might set myself a limit of 1 hour and tell them this was my approach, this was how far I got. I've heard of 30-60 hour workloads given to applicants to 'top five' companies and it's just ridiculous. As are the stories of interviewers who have no technical skills themselves and are just looking for a canned response (Google, looking at you). I was going to say that the best approach I've seen are companies that put up interesting puzzles and security challenges on their website. The technical skills required aren't _that_ high, but certainly require an amount of ingenuity, persistence and just plain being interested in tinkering that they feel suits their company profile. The applicants can solve or try to solve these challenges, do writeups and probably get interviews just based on those. Granted, I can also understand someone looking at 50 companies all giving them 4-10 hour workloads to MAYBE get an interview might feel frustrated and overloaded. It's a classic egg-and-chicken problem. If I were to start looking for a job from scratch I'd probably solve a bunch of code wars challenges and security CTFs, make a blog and just link my writeups and blog to applications. |