|
|
|
|
|
|
by nim2020
2171 days ago
|
|
|
I find it interesting that many people hold so tightly onto the "it is not native unless it is written entirely in %my_favorite_language%". I think a little controversy is good, but what the heck does native mean anymore? Wasn't it really invented as a kind of "shaming" because front-end developers were never considered "real programmers" and when hybrid apps came out some folks felt the need to line their pockets with this differentiation? Don't get me wrong, I am very well acquainted with the tragedies of JS - and the propensity of amateurs to just "do it all" in a single-threaded webrenderer. In fact, I think that this is why most of the first and second generation "web-apps" built on cordova and electron were such poor performers. But nevertheless, what we are trying to do with Tauri is to open up the boundaries between development communities and leverage the particular strengths of each of them. So if you don't feel Tauri is "native" enough, then maybe you are missing the point. |
|
|
There's a weird impedance mismatch in the UIs of any non native apps that comes simply from recreating the UI elements and not using the system provided ones. This isn't an aspect of trying to 'feel superior' to JS devs, but a reflection of the real trade-offs of the technique. And I say this as the lead from a traditionally systems oriented team that's about to ship our first electron app. We took a look at the costs, and decided that in this particular case the tradeoffs were worth it, but it's not an easy decision.
And one thing I'll say is that a piece of what makes electron attractive at the organizational level is the fact that it doesn't use the system libraries. That greatly reduces QA burden by not having a spread of different versions of underlying infra to deal with. As an enduser I'd love if all the chrome/blink based apps on my machine (let's see, chrome, spotify, vscode, slack are all running) shared resources, but if they had to test against different versions of runtime or each version of their code they released, they probably wouldn't be using this model in the first place.