Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by throwaway9870 2171 days ago
> blackballed

Honest question - Is that a racist term? Doesn't appear to be based on Google search, but I see people removing words with black in them such as "blacklist" so I am curious.

2 comments

No. It refers to a supposed part of the process of joining the Freemasons. The members of the lodge vote anonymously whether to accept a prospective member by depositing a white or black ball into a closed box, with the black ball representing a “no” vote. So “blackballed” refers to some exclusive group excluding outsiders.

I’m not a Mason so I don’t know if this factual, but that’s the idea.

Of course, someone could be blackballed because they are black—if a particular Masonic lodge had racist members—but it’s not inherent to the concept.

So no, but really yes. It's just as racist as "black list" and "white list".
That’s more the general case of the word “black” being used both to denote bad/negative/disallowed and to denote people of African ancestry. But there isn’t a specifically racial meaning to either “blackballed” or “blacklist”.
For me, racism is about the intent. Sometime, those are words, but most times they aren't about words.

So it depends.