Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ElFitz 2177 days ago
Yes. And the gifting party doesn't have to even bother pretending they care enough about said recipient to try and figure what that person would like / could like and don't know it yet.

I don't see how any of that is brilliant. Might as well write a check. Or just don't bother with a gift at all. It's what I do with most people I don't care enough about.
1 comments
sumedh 2177 days ago
Clearly you are one of those people who takes gifting very seriously, some dont. Its brilliant because its the right product for people who want to give something but dont have time or dont feel comfortable asking probing questions about what the recipient likes.

Giving cheque/cash feels tacky to me.

link
scpedicini 2177 days ago
But giving a more restricted version of currency that can only be used at one place feels less tacky?
link
colanderman 2177 days ago
Gift cards demonstrate a modicum of forethought/planning, albeit on the order of a Hallmark card. Cash says "this is what I found in my wallet on the drive here". Check falls somewhere in between, but with the added inconvenience of the recipient having to figure out how to deposit it.

Gift cards have the added benefit to the gifter that, upon being spent, the giftee has a chance to associate them with the purchased good or service. Cash and check, being added to an amorphous fungible pool, confer no such benefit for the gifter.

What I haven't figured out is where on these axes lies a printed-out QR code granting ownership of a Bitcoin wallet. Unfortunately Google tells me these actually exist: https://bitcoinpaperwallet.com/holiday-design/

link
hnick 2177 days ago
Before cheap plastic gift cards existed, we used to just hand over cash and write in the card "get a nice book and let me know when you do" or something. So that's hopefully a little less tacky ;)
link
Symbiote 2177 days ago
When I became old enough that more distant relatives didn't really know what to buy me, they'd send £5 and a request that I spend it on clothes, a book, a day out with friends or whatever.

Usually, they'd send a banknote in perfect condition, or a cheque if it was by post.

I'm now too old for these gifts, but my youngest sibling gets the same instructions, and a future-dated transfer to his bank account.

link
sumedh 2177 days ago
Yes and there are gift cards which can be used at multiple stores
link