[1MachineElf]

One of the things the Planck Rev 6 PCB made me realize is how important hotswap is for me personally. First, I have _dozens_ of interesting mechanical keyboard kits which are un-built because I simply don't have the convenient time & place to set up my soldering equipment. Second, some of the kits I've managed to build have bricked on me due to unexplained microcontroller problems, and while I have an expensive desoldering gun, it's still a PITA to use/maintain/clean, so hot-swap sockets solve that switch recoverey problem in a very convenient way. Lastly, of course, the ability to change switches on a whim is nice on it's own.

This M60 keyboard builds on all of that by providing a socketed microcontroller, so even if it isn't the layout I prefer, I'll still look into buying one for the sole sake of supporting this work. Open source design & easy-to-program QMK-ish firmware are also huge plusses.

I also love the fact that pictured are the new Kailh Silent Pink switches. I got a small amount a couple weeks ago and want to get more, but they've sold out at US distributors. If the M60 is ever offered as a "full kit" then I hope those switches are an option.

[kfihihc]

You got the point :)

Hoping you will enjoy M60.

[dmix]

Maybe a dumb question but why don't more mech keyboards have hotswap? That seems like a great feature I don't remember ever coming across in the few times I've bought them.

[1MachineElf]

They have a bit of a learning curve, because if the switch legs aren't straightened out before being pushed in, there's a chance they can be irreversibly crumpled. It can be a hard lesson if the switches were expensive.

De-soldered switches are especially prone to this problem because the leftover solder on the legs makes them 1) more brittle, and 2) irregularly shaped, so switches like vintage blacks are kind of a no-go for hotswap.

Some have reported the hotswap sockets pop out when forcing switches in, which I personally haven't witnessed myself. The impact ranges from a trivial matter of needing to apply more solder to the pad, all the way up to the hot swap socket ripping off the pad itself (very difficult to repair).

Hotswap sockets are less secure than switches that are directly soldered on, which means that one typically will want to use them in combination with a switch plate. Switch plates, however, have the counter-intuitive effect of raising the pitch of your keyboard's sound profile. Most people don't realize this. By a lot of standards, a plate-less keyboard does sound better, and with hotswap all those keys will start looking slightly crooked fast.

These nitpicks are things most users will never notice, but people who have been in the hobby for a long time do notice them, and those folks happen to be very vocal and influential. Then there's also the fact that anyone who is willing to design a PCB is probably savvy enough to desolder without issues. These factors are why there appears to be a strong anti-hotswap movement.

Overall, I'd still recommend using hotswap.

[pattato]

Not a dumb question at all. Hotswappable switches are becoming more common but many keyboard enthusiasts still are iffy about them. Hotswappable switches tend to have a bit more wobble that their soddered counterparts, but in my opinion the benefit of being able to change out the switches outweighs the wobble.

Those who are confident in their switch choice will prefer less wobble, and probably have multiple keyboards anyway with different switches.

[jolmg]

I'm getting the feeling that hotswap in this context doesn't refer to being able to plug/unplug the keyboard from the computer while the computer is on[1], since I've never seen a keyboard that wasn't able to do that. So, this may be a dumber question, but what's being referred to as hotswap in this context?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_swapping

[hnarn]

> A keyboard being hot-swappable means the PCB (which, simply put, is the circuit board inside the keyboard) has special sockets so that you can click switches into place and pull them out without ever needing to touch a soldering gun.

From a Google search :-)

[Nightshaxx]

This is acctually becoming a more common feature. I recently purchased a new mechanical keyboard and a lot of the newer designs are host swappable.