Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ruairidhc 2174 days ago
Scottish Gaelic has been proclaimed dying for as long as I remember. Despite my name being Gaelic (I am Scottish), the amount of "public" (tax) money that has been poured into the language by our devolved government (>£28 million/year) is appauling. The phrase "that which is falling should also be pushed" comes to mind.

Edit: typo

3 comments

28 million GBP a year seems pretty small, budget-wise. How much is that per capita?
The Scottish budget is £34B. So Scotland is spending 0.08% of their budget on Gaelic education, which seems pretty inconsequential.
£5.27 (~7.86 USD)per Scottish resident, or £488 (607.78 USD) per resident speaker of Gaelic, if you go by Wikipedia’s population statistics.

[Edit: or, if you go by the article’s 11000 active speakers number, £2545, 3170 USD]

Worth noting that the budget for "Gaelic" is part of education, ie 24m or so is spent on standard schooling which happens to be done in Gaelic
So, do you feel that the money has been misappropriated? I mean, should it have been spent differently (for the same cause)?

I am asking because I understand the issue that you feel regarding spending the money but do you think that it should not have been spent in this cause at all?

How much do they spend on Scots? It seems odd to teach the south eastern half of the population Gaelic, if their ancestral language is Scots.