Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JoeAltmaier 5570 days ago
...they stated. When they were "asking" to have the app taken down. Not banning, not legislating. Just asking.
3 comments

'Just asking' is a lot worse than following the legislative process. They are trying to use their influence to accomplish an effectively legislative outcome without oversight. This creates a dangerous gray area between law and intimidation. It's similar to when Visa, Mastercard, etc. were 'just asked' to stop dealing with Wikileaks. In fact, it is common for dictators and totalitarian regimes to rule through 'just asking' instead of law. Not a good precedent.
I think that statement includes an implicit threat of possible legislation action if necessary.
Apple complying with their request and passing legislation have the same outcome.
Apple complying with the request just means it's unavailable on the Apple/iPhone platform. Legislating it means it's unavailable on any platform.