[whatshisface]

They should be testing it on something that involves more remembering and less thinking, like microbiology. Physics is the absolute worst subject to test any new book-writing method in, because the book practically doesn't matter; it's all in what happens inside the student's head as they do the exercises. The fact that the Moore method has half a chance of working for topology students shows beyond a shadow of a doubt that for highly logic-based fields like physics and math that the book matters so little that the absence of any book or lecture at all will still result in the material being taught!