Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by MintelIE 2197 days ago
As the amount of administration support staff and special needs paraprofessionals skyrocketed, the resources allocated to regular students and teachers have dwindled. People feel good about having students with special needs included in regular classes but it has caused an enormous reallocation of resources, shifting massive cash and attention to the lowest performing students.

There was a book about this once, Harrison Bergeron.
1 comments
sharkmerry 2197 days ago
Is it entirely due to re-allocation to special needs education?

Seems like with population growth, we are trying to educate more and more kids, and unlike in the past, we dont just discard that parts that would be expensive or difficult.

In the past, we ignored the problem so it wasnt factored into budgets, head counts. There needs to be more money overall for education. It returns more than $1 for every $1 invested over the long term.

link
MintelIE 2197 days ago
It varies by district but my wife is a teacher (now) and she has worked in several schools where the special education budget met or exceeded the non-special, while serving only 3-5% of the school's enrolled children.
link
sharkmerry 2197 days ago
I understand that. but what is the suggested alternative? These students simply cost more to educate, is that the students fault though?

Leave them behind and underfunded like in the past? Lock them up?

link
thejynxed 2195 days ago
My wife also teaches these sorts of children and the vast majority of them seldom improve beyond a 5th or 6th grade level, and many of the "smarter" ones with milder disabilities end up in jail at some point after being graduated (most typically for sexual, theft, violence, and drug offenses) out of the system since they can no longer be failed, yet they basically can't truly be taught how to properly function in society since they can't even properly comprehend laws or how they work, as they only have basic reading capability and comprehension of even simple children's books.

Closing institutions insteading of reforming and modernizing them for these sorts of people was indeed a mistake.

link