[ResidentSleeper]

Whether or not it's comparable depends on the level of distinction you're trying to make. Obviously, CPUs don't think or experience the world (but on the other hand that kind of "feature" seems increasingly likely to be implementable in software, even if our current CPU architectures are rather unsuitable for that goal). However, if we're gonna talk about energy efficiency and computation performance, now that it has become evident that the brain is merely a kind of a computer, we can definitely look for parallels.

[kalcode]

> now that it has become evident that the brain is merely a kind of a computer

I am ignorant in this area. But I keep reading how brains are nothing like computers the more we learn. Your statement seems to suggest otherwise and id love to read about it. Can you drop something where I can start exploring about how the brain has become more evident that it's merely a kind of computer? Thanks!

[whatshisface]

The brain is thought to be merely a computer in the original sense of a long strip of paper along with a scribe and a rulebook. The logic is, a Turing machine can simulate quantum electrodynamics to an arbitrary degree of accuracy. Then, two beliefs about physics and the structure of the brain are included:

1. There is nothing going on in the brain that would require simulation to infinite accuracy. Not even a chaotic system would have this property, because they take a finite time to "blow up" an initial uncertainty, and the smaller the initial uncertainty the longer they take to blow up. For this proposition to be violated there would have to be an undiscovered fininite-time nondeterministic blowup, which is unlikely, but I've heard rumblings that we haven't proven that it can't happen in Navier-Stokes. So maybe it can happen in the brain.

2. There is nothing going on in the brain that depends on nuclear physics or anything more "powerful" than quantum electrodynamics.

I have not seen any evidence that 1 or 2 aren't true for the brain, so that puts something behind saying it's "merely a computer."

[checkyoursudo]

If you are looking for a book for an introduction, I would suggest Mindware by Andy Clark is pretty reasonable. Pub 2014; ISBN: 9780199828159