Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hughmungus 2208 days ago
We ask police to deal with mobs of violent criminals then get angry at them when they push someone, it's laughable.

It's naive to expect perfect policing in such situations.

1 comments

So you think perfection is a reasonable expectation for protestors?

Your standards don’t seem consistent or reasonable.

Do you believe this invalidates a cause, peaceful protest, or protestors?
I believe that various examples of this and numerous people being killed invalidates the claim that the national guard shouldn't be on the street with clear curfews to protect life.
I agree that it is a dangerous situation and also want to protect lives and the rights of citizens.

Are safety and the right to peacefully assemble so at odds?

The national guard protecting the lives and rights of its citizens is a far cry from being dominated as a part of a battle space.

If we consider that there may be substance to other viewpoints as opposed to only opposition to our own we could work at addressing some of the root or common goals instead of focusing on division.

Why don’t states and or citizens feel comfortable utilizing the national guard?

Is it reasonable to fear an escalation which may place the American people and their constitutional rights in jeopardy?

Are there approaches that would deescalate the situation that should be favored over those which risk even greater division (in particular between the citizens and the military )?

I mean establishing a curfew during the night, not stopping peaceful protest.