Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ccostes 2214 days ago
Agreed, the "if anything management is getting screwed here" got me good. Still not convinced management, who walked away with millions in cash, got screwed, but it was a well-crafted article.

Edit: I should clarify that by "walking away with millions" I was referring to their normal cash comp. 2019 CEO cash comp was $3.6MM, and she got $700k as a retention bonus.
2 comments
kube-system 2214 days ago
Do companies really have any other choice but to hand out a bunch of cash to senior management? Nobody really wants to hang around and go down with the ship, but someone has to stick around to manage the reorganization. These weren't bonuses to "walk away" with cash, these were bonuses for them to stick around.
link
mdorazio 2214 days ago
Where else were they going to go right now? The entire auto industry, and especially the rental side, are effectively stalled and not hiring new people. In a normally functioning market I would agree with you, but in this case it really comes across as a ridiculous and needless handout.
link
kube-system 2214 days ago
Maybe the market downturn can account for why these bonuses are less than we normally see. But these are senior execs we're talking about; it is not uncommon for them to switch industries. Their job specialty is managing a company, not renting cars. The current Hertz CEO has only been in the car rental industry for two years.
link
mdorazio 2214 days ago
I'll repeat the question then - where are they going to go? Unless you think all of them could transition to SaaS companies I'm not seeing how it's relevant that they're senior execs.
link
kube-system 2214 days ago
Their current CEO spent 28 years at Walmart, and Walmart (as well as several other retailers) has had great financial performance recently.

Or many of them could probably afford to sit on their butt at their beach home for a few years and ride out the recession.

I don't see any reason why they couldn't work at a SaaS company though. It's relevant that they're senior execs because their job position is so far removed from the actual product that they really only need a general understanding of it.

link
mdorazio 2214 days ago
I'm going to guess you've never seen how senior executive recruiting actually works. I regularly work with senior-level executives in automotive, tier 1 supplier, and software companies and can tell you for a fact that right now these people would not easily find jobs anywhere else. Without the retention payouts their options would have been 1) keep working through the wind-down and receive their normal level of pay and benefits or 2) have no job and get the 55k/yr equivalent in unemployment with no benefits. I 100% do not believe very many, if any, would have opted for the latter option and sitting around on the beach. This payout was unnecessary.
link
tadfisher 2214 days ago
$16 million over 340 employees (if you believe the article) is $47,058.82 per. Not exactly a golden parachute if you ask me.
link
ideals 2214 days ago
Assuming even distributing of funds among those 340 people is a little hard to believe as well.
link
ccostes 2214 days ago
> walking away with millions

I was referring to their normal compensation, should have made that clear.

According to the article the CEO got $700k from the $16MM, and her 2019 cash comp was $3.6MM.

link