Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fenwick67 2212 days ago
> Mozilla cannot fix Web until they start attacking FAANG

They already attack Facebook (they put Facebook in Facebook purgatory by default, don't they?) and I'm not sure what they need to go after Apple, Amazon or Netflix over, I think you are really just mean Google here.

2 comments

In which ways has Mozilla attacked Facebook? One way I'm aware of is their "Facebook Container" extension, which is basically the same as their Multi-Containers extension, with the key difference of being preconfigured for Facebook. Last I checked there is a similarly preconfigured extension for Google, but that one is from a 3rd party extension developer, not Mozilla (I have a very hard time recommending 3rd party extensions to other people since I do not know if those extensions will remain trustworthy...)

This suggests to me that improving the UX of the generic Multi-Container extension should be a higher priority. As it stands, doing something as simple as creating a new container for a site and then having that site always open in that container takes numerous less-than intuitive user actions.

1) Click "+" (tooltip: create new container)

2) Fill out a name for the container, and choose from a very limited choice of colors and icons (only 8 colors and 12 icons; 96 total combinations)

3) Open a new tab with that container, and navigate back to the website

4) Select "Always open in [container name]"

5) Open a new tab, nagivate back to the website

6) Select "Remember my decision"

7) Select "Open in [container name]"

Step 2 should not have such inane artificial restrictions. Step 3 should happen automatically. Step 6 and 7 should not happen at all because my choice in Step 4 should be respected.

They have a list of domains to exclude from their so-called tracking "protection" and that list contains Google and Facebook. I wouldn't call that attacking by any means.

The Facebook Container is absolutely pointless when you account for fingerprinting and IP address tracking.

>The Facebook Container is absolutely pointless when you account for fingerprinting and IP address tracking.

The former being something they actively support defending against with privacy.resistFingerprinting?