[majormajor]

You're arguing "containers give you a chance of keeping everything pristine" but the claim was "you end up with a more robust system if you don't thing 'everything should be pristine' should be a precondition."

I'm not sure I agree with the original poster though. I both dislike doing dev inside a container and dislike complicated manual dev environment setups. Containers for deps like dbs are more reasonable. This is faster perf-wise, more friendly for fancy tooling/debuggers and such, and it introduces just enough heterogeneity that you may catch weird quirks that could bite you on update in the future.

But you should be able to spin up/down new deploys easily, without having to do manual provisioning and such, which means the env on your servers should be container-like, even if it's not directly a container. Pristine and freshly-initialized. And then if you regularly upgrade the dependency versions, from linux version to third part lib versions to runtime versions, then you will still avoid the brittleness.