Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Ao7bei3s 2222 days ago
Counter-argument(?): I've seen a product where production ran in Docker, but development was a mix of Mac, Windows and every popular Linux distribution, on laptops, on-prem servers and in the cloud, as per each devs preference. Components could be run separately. The product could run anywhere.

Then standardization crept into development. Two years later, it was essentially impossible to run it outside Docker built by Bamboo, deployed by Jenkins in on-prem OpenStack, components were tightly coupled (database wasn't configurable anymore, filesystem had to look a certain way, etc.), and it required very specific library versions, which largely haven't been updated ever again, and cannot be updated easily anymore by now. No individual team had an overview of everything inside the container anymore (we ended up with 3 Redis, 1 Mongo and 1 Postgres in that container. The project to split it apart again was cancelled after a while). Production and development were the same container images, but in completely different environments.

If you want code paths to work, you need to exercise them regularly through tests. Likewise, if you want a flexible codebase, you need to use that flexibility constantly. Control what goes into production, but be flexible during development.

2 comments

The same mistake can be done outside of containers though. Any software needs to be maintained and its dependancies kept up to date. Containers might give the feeling that it's not a necessity anymore as it allows to spin up an environment in one command, but in the end those dependencies are still there.

My experience is the opposite. I once had started a job with totally outdated software that couldn't be run anywhere else than the old server it was currently running and had never been touched since 2008. We were able in the end to bring everything back up to date and create containers that are: - easy to update - allow devs to work on their favourite os (windows, linux or macos) - does not require someone help devs to fix their dev environment regularly

So much this.