Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by leibnitz27 2230 days ago
I have an OSS 'fun project' - I'm still amazed by the number of issues/emails I get raised which say:

"You should rewrite in" / "Why does't it do" / "Make it do".

It's nice that people are using it. I generally (try to) assume this is a language/cultural thing, and people don't realise that they're coming across as a bit rude in English.

But, it would be nicer if people approached commenting on OSS by first thinking "Author is doing this for fun, unpaid, and I'm getting something nice out of his/her time", THEN writing their comment.

I'd get the same issues raised, and that's fine. But the language might read a bit nicer.

2 comments

Thanks for acknowledging this might be a language or cultural thing. I’m sure this kind of „smalltalk“ is appreciated when you put your free time into what others maybe use for their job.

One thing I would like to suggest is to have a question in the feature or bug issue template to ask what people use the lib for and what they like about it. Maybe even set expectations.

I see similar types of reactions to intra-team pull request comments. I think it's a facet of the facelessness of online comments.

I think there's a lot of scope for changing the way that comments on issue trackers and pull requests are taken in order to make the interactions more human and friendly.