Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jonsen 2232 days ago
I pick 333 doors, and Monty opens 333 doors?
1 comments

No the variation with 1000 doors is that you open 1 door, Monty opens 998 doors and asks if you want to switch.
Yeah, the use of 3 doors, and the bit where one is opened just kinda hides what’s happening. Which is that you’re actually choosing between one random door, or ALL the other doors.
The Eureka moment for me was similar, but slightly different. Consider a variant game with N doors. You pick a door, then Monty offers you two switch your payout to "the best single result from the remaining N-1 doors". Clearly, you would swap.

Now set N to 3, and consider that, by opening a door without the prize, that's exactly what Monty's offering you.