Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by timinman 5583 days ago
"To be second to the Soviet Union in establishing an outpost on the moon would be disastrous to our nation's prestige and in turn to our democratic philosophy."

Though it is probably easier to see now than it was during the cold war, that claim (especially the last part) is flawed logic.

Although countries may need to use military force for self-preservation, functional ideologies do not need to be propped up by being first, more prestigious, or impressive.

1 comments

Actually the success of ideologies is more closely linked to the success of its implementations than its merit. For instance, the success of monarchies for such a long period in history was based on their stability. Likewise, it could be argued that the resurgence of democracy was based on instability in the existing regimes, more than any greater merit in the ideology. If the Soviets had been more successful, I can guarantee we'd be saying how the merit of equality of income is why the Soviets were successful, but we'd be wrong, just as saying the merit of democracy is why the US was successful.