Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dang 2244 days ago
This is a stub root comment to collect comments about website formatting, which have been transferred hither.
7 comments

Could this be done for every thread? The comments that are only about the metadata rather than the content of the articles posted can be quite tiring to sift through.
Certainly thinking about it. It's the first time we've done this.
You've been saying recently that HN is like a water cooler.

I feel like disabled people talking about how frustrating they find it when a well funded company makes accessibility mistakes are a useful part of that water cooler conversation.

I know some people find this meta discussion about website accessibility tedious, but perhaps those people should try to show a bit of insight into just how tedious disabled people find it to have to keep making this point, year after year.

(FWIW, I did stop making comments about the accessibility of sites after you said this 5 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9238739 )

I don't know a good solution. Those concerns are for sure legitimate, and at the same time it's tiresome when complaints about website formatting crop up often in threads. Especially because meta complaints show up about those complaints, and then meta meta, and so on.

Perhaps the solution is for people to express accessibility concerns to the proprietors of the websites in question, instead of to forums where the concerns are most likely not going to be seen by the people who would need to fix them.

The watercooler aspect of HN goes back to the beginning, btw: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8314 - though it's true that I've been citing it more lately.

On mobile, the text is barely readable
I found this to be quite readable. Nicely designed site!
It's useful to compare the desktop and mobile versions. On desktop it's nice. On mobile it's unreadable for many people - so much so that I think it'd be breaking some disability accessibility laws.
Correct me if I’m wrong but as of April 2020 there is no legal definition for what makes a website accessible. Seems like WCAG 2 is referenced in some court cases but is not a law.
Why not just have white text on a white background? No idea what's in the article
Only if you disable JavaScript it's white text on white background.

It's current trend to write CSS styles in JavaScript.

On Desktop I see black text on white background, although the videos don't seem to load.
Reading mode to the rescue!
It's like #222 on #FFF ... not bad contrast?
Not sure why, but on my phone it's barely readable.
Night mode or dark theme related maybe?

Some sites don't set a body background color thinking it will always be white.

Might be related.

The font could be made bold..
Extra thin font violates accessibility standards.
Firefox reader view saves me on a regular basis.
Oh wow, that contrast is terrible (Chrome Mobile, Android).
That website is a crime against humanity.
Maybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to this one.