Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by LaEc 2239 days ago
Are healthcare outcomes worse in the US than other first world countries? Life expectancy is endogenous to variables like diet and exercise. Looking at cancer survival rates, the US is best at some and mediocre at others but other countries are not "objectively better"[0].

Is health expenditure in the US higher than in other countries? Yes, but that is because the US is rich, really rich. If we plot US Real Household Income against healthcare consumption, the US is perfectly inline with global trends[1].

[0] https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/research/articles/concord-2....

[1] https://randomcriticalanalysis.com/2018/11/19/why-everything...
2 comments
orwin 2238 days ago
At least in France, the liberalisation of our healthcare system from 2005 to today came with a huge drop in efficiency and increase in price (subsidized ofc, as it is still universal healthcare, but still)[0][1]. Act tarification and the bureaucratic ocntrol of the hospital mean that more time is needed for service chiefs to do paperwork instead of... curing people, and the huge increas in private care use is an indicator of the public health service. Also as more and more acts were driven off universal healthcare to private insurance (that your employer have to get for you if you don't have one, but that is paid on your salary) was in fact an increase in cost for everyone. Public healthcare administration cost in France is 18% of their budget [2]. Care to guess what private insurance company administration cost is? 27% for swisslife (i don't know if this account for privatised profits or not sadly).

Also nurses and other low-level health workers have low pay compared to the rest of the first world as their salaries did not increase as much as other wokers.

[0] https://www.who.int/whr/2000/en/whr00_en.pdf

[1] https://www.commonwealthfund.org/chart/2017/health-care-syst...

[2] (doing the math myself i found 13% but i think that's because they are also paying the retirement pensions)

link
Ididntdothis 2239 days ago
The US is obviously not rich enough to cover all or even most citizens. And a lot of people are not rich enough to avoid bankruptcy because of medical bills.
link