[tly_alex]

Living pay check to pay check is considered risky in a lot of country, but due to the high available credits from credit card or personal loads, ppl in US don't feel like the need of saving. This pandemic could be the start of more saving.

[DoreenMichele]

This makes me wonder what the differences are in various countries that help skew those numbers one way or the other.

I know in the US, how much debt you have has zero bearing on your ability to qualify for welfare programs, but savings can negatively impact your ability to qualify. So owing less doesn't qualify you for more aid, but having too much savings can screw you out of benefits in an emergency situation.

Some countries have programs that provide health benefits just because you exist. In the US, a lot of our benefits programs are "needs based," which means you have to qualify for aid and one of those qualifications is that you don't have savings because as little as $2000 in the bank can disqualify you.

I don't think it's as one dimensional as the above comment seems to suggest. But I bet there are inherent incentives in the US to not bother to save for various reasons. It would be interesting to see that investigated in earnest.

[tly_alex]

Interesting. I didn't know the US aid depends on the saving. How does govvernment know how much saving each person has? There's no formal process to report savings. On the other hand, the tax reporting would include annual income, which I thought is how most of the aid looks at. For example, the latest $1200 won't distributed to ppl with high income.

[DoreenMichele]

The $1200 stimulus check is something of an aberration. You typically need to apply for things like food stamps, Section 8 housing or Medicaid (our government health insurance for the poor).

When you apply, you basically swear this is true to the best of knowledge and if it isn't you can be accused of fraud and potentially charged with criminal activity, or just have the money taken back in some cases. (My knowledge of the system is limited, but I was on food stamps for a while. Having something like $2000 in savings can disqualify you, iirc.)

[tly_alex]

Thanks for the data point! That make sense.