[howlin]

There are still frontier nations out there. Russia, Greenland, Outback Australia, the Canadian Territories. Perhaps Alaska.

But the continental US is a developed land with dense cities. Your idea of what your liberties should be don't justify the drastic externalities you will inflict on your neighbors.

[DoreenMichele]

There's damn few places in the US with population density akin to Europe or Asia.

The last big city I lived in, Fresno, is low density sprawl. The culture there is like half a million cowboys decided to move to the suburbs. They put on their cowboy crap to go to concerts at their major park. It's bizarre.

We also generally have shit public transit.

You cannot tell me that lock down is the only possible way to handle the pandemic in the incredibly low average population density of most of the US. Give me a break.

[yongjik]

Fresno, CA has population density of 1,761.69/km2. That's not too far from Daegu, South Korea (2,818/km2), where 6,807 were infected so far and 142 people died. They stopped it only through really aggressive testing and contact tracing.

I'm so tired of this America-is-so-special argument. Freaking Mississippi has 2,260 patients now. Now what?

[DoreenMichele]

Mississippi is one of the poorest places in the US. It's got problems akin to a third world country.

Now what? I'm sure you think that's a rhetorical question, but today is your unlucky day because I've spent the last 19 years getting healthier while the world says it cannot be done and generally acts like a butt to me.

Now we actively create a world where public bathrooms aren't health hazards to use at all. I propose we get Walmart to write that handbook. Their bathrooms are generally pretty damn good and there are lots of establishments where I don't want to set foot in their restroom.

Now we create a world where it's normal to call ahead or order online and pick-up instead of dining out or milling about waiting for our order because we all just showed up and then ordered.

Now we create cultural norms where you don't blow your nose at the god-damned conference table or restaurant table, jebus.

Now we create cultural norms like bowing instead of shaking hands.

Now we create architectural standards like using copper for stair rails because it's antimicrobial.

Making people a prisoner of their homes while our economy gets flushed down the toilet isn't our only option. That assumption is ignorant on the face of it. There's always more than one way to solve a problem.

[yongjik]

I genuinely agree that each of them is a noble cause that will make America a better place, but unfortunately, none of them are an answer to "We have a pandemic going on here, now what?"

First you make a absurd assertion that most of the US has much lower population density than Europe or Asia - that's true only if you measure by land area, not people, but then it's irrelevant: land doesn't contact COVID19, people do. In any case, it stopped being relevant about two weeks ago when the US overtook Italy - America's lower population density clearly didn't stop the disease.

There's a crisis going on, and I'm sorry that you will likely be affected much more by it than I will, and I agree that it's a social injustice that should be addressed in the long term, but that doesn't mean you can just wave away the crisis because you have a moral high ground. Coronavirus doesn't care.

[DoreenMichele]

My understanding is that it's really bad in New York, one of the few places with population density similar to Europe.

I have no idea why you assume I will be impacted more than you. Although dirt poor, I already do remote work from home and hardly go out. My life has hardly been impacted at all. A few meetings I attend were cancelled (and now people are answering my emails for a change).

The pandemic has mostly had a positive impact on my life because the rest of the world is practicing germ control for a change and pollution levels have dropped dramatically.

I mean feel free to support my Patreon or otherwise kick a few bucks my way. I can always use more cash. But my kids sit around gleefully announcing "Coronavirus is the best thing that's ever happened to our lives" and giggling about all the free games they are downloading.

[lnreddy]

"Now what ?" - Now we practice common sense social distancing and wait for the virus to take its course. No need to overreact and go full China style authoritarian lockdown. And yes, America is exceptional even if it annoys you.

[watwut]

America is not going to adopt common sense social distancing enough to be able to let virus run its course. That would requires massive cooperation in good faith from both parties and most states. Looking how things go on, it won't happen.

You are more likely to see epidemic being used to disadvantage other side, to make voting harder for this or that group and massive amount of lies then cooperation in good faith.

Which would had negative implications for democracies in rest of world too.

[lnreddy]

You'd be surprised. There's vast land west of the Mississippi that is still rugged and relatively undeveloped. I speak more in terms of the frontier mindset, but I digress.

[guscost]

> Your idea of what your liberties should be don't justify the drastic externalities you will inflict on your neighbors.

With respect, that’s up to my neighbors, not the government.