[jkhdigital]

Everything you've said is spot on, especially the last sentence--there is a lot to criticize.

The issue here is not really about the actual economic impact of the virus. No amount of money printing or loan issuance can recover the real economic output that has been lost. There is real destruction of capital and wealth because humans and their toys require continuous consumption to maintain homeostasis but production has fallen off a cliff.

What makes everything so insanely complicated is that the real economy is intimately tied up in a financial economy that compounds the distress. Missing debt payments has massive repercussions for both individuals and companies which can far exceed the value of the missed payment. We have built a legal and financial framework around our economy (under the banner of "risk management") that binds us to mutual destruction when things go badly. This is why the popping of the mortgage bubble in 2008 nearly annihilated the global banking system rather than just bankrupting a bunch of risky mortgage underwriters and maybe taking down a bank or two.

Our solution appears to be just making sure no one misses a payment by handing out cash like Santa Claus on a bender. I guess it does the job, but the level of moral hazard this invites is troubling (to put it lightly).