Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by samatman 2270 days ago
Your comment is low quality and doesn't add to the discussion.

novok, by contrast, makes all the same points, correctly, and without all the histrionics.

It can simultaneously be true that the technical 'dividend' is enjoyed by practically everyone in the developed world, and that the necessities of ordinary life have become more expensive, saving rates have plummeted, and precarity has been normalized.

Indeed, this appears to be the case. Expecting every comment on the Internet to cover everything salient about a given topic is unrealistic. Good thing we have the nested forum format, so that other people can fill things in!

1 comments

> Your comment is low quality and doesn't add to the discussion.

Please do not make personal attacks against people on HN. There is literally no reason to tell someone that their on-topic and very-relevant comment/response "is low quality doesn't add to the discussion". It is petty.

> Expecting every comment on the Internet to cover everything salient about a given topic is unrealistic. Good thing we have the nested forum format ...

Again, my response was utilizing the HN format to fill in some missing information and make a very relevant point about improved formatting of arguments in general.

> It can simultaneously be true that the technical 'dividend' is enjoyed by practically everyone in the developed world, and that the necessities of ordinary life have become more expensive, saving rates have plummeted, and precarity has been normalized.

It CAN be true, yes. It can also be true that the technical dividend is far out-weighed by rising costs. It can ALSO be true that globalization has changed the pricing dynamic mentioned in GP more so than a "technical dividend".

By "personal attacks" do you mean comments such as this one:

> Sigh ... I hope this style of commentary comes to a swift end on the internet (and especially places like HN)

?