[stronglikedan]

> for some reason

They recommend against wearing medical to help cull the shortage, and they recommend against wearing non-medical because they can provide a false sense of security, especially when worn incorrectly. Both very good reasons, IMO.

I just assume that anyone wearing a mask is doing so because they're infected, as per the recommendations, and I'm giving them a wide berth.

[lonelappde]

Not good reason. Lying to people to try to manipulate their presumed stupidity for their own good doesn't work. We went through this with the malarkey around claiming "advising abstinence is safer than offering condoms for STD protection"

[dumbfounder]

Yes, but the messaging is not consistent which leads to public distrust, which might actually be worse. Don't wear masks, they don't help! But we need them because they do actually help! It's obviously not that simple but that's the way it's being perceived.

[stronglikedan]

> which leads to public distrust

Maybe a minority, as there will always be, but I think most people are aware of the difference between medical and non-medical masks, and feel the messaging is consistent.

[anon102010]

Definitely not - instead of emphasizing production the US has had this horrible no mask message - likely resulting in deaths

[throwaway32120]

I've seen no evidence that masks give people a false sense of security. If anything, it seems to be the opposite. People report that when they wear masks, people move away from them, and employers have asked them not to wear them because they might make the customers feel unsafe. They're a giant reminder that things aren't normal and that we're in the middle of a massive pandemic. This is a good thing.

If mask use becomes mandatory, will there still be groups of people standing in the middle of supermarket shouting to each other? Sure, just like there are now. The difference is those people will at least have masks on.

[analog31]

>>> ...and I'm giving them a wide berth.

Another reason to wear a mask.

[stronglikedan]

Non-medical masks don't keep stuff out. They just keep stuff in, so the only reason to wear it is to not spread your water droplets when you sneeze or cough. Medical masks keep stuff out, but are in short supply.

I think I'm helping more by going with the recommendations and not wearing a mask. Some people feel better wearing them, and that's fine too.

[anandoza]

I think you might have misunderstood the parent comment (since your reply is somewhat of a non sequitur). My interpretation was that "if I wear a mask, then people will assume I'm infected and give me space, which is actually just better for me regardless of the mask's direct efficacy".

[leemoore]

This binary assertion is fairly broadly given and I think it’s a narrow view that is a subtle form of unintentional disinformation that endangers. Any reduction of viral load on exposure is by nature better. The intensity of initial viral Old can help determine whether you get covid 19 and how strong it hits. It’s difficult to believe that some worth of cloth covering will have absolutely zero reduction of viral load. No you shouldn’t think it’s a comprehensive protection. But it’s silly to handwave away as useless as many do. Anything that limits spread should be encouraged. People still need to minimize going out, but if they have to, and have nothing else, dismissing all other masks as useless is not helpful.

[JoeAltmaier]

I'm not so good with spreading my own potential risk around. It's essentially selfish to not wear a mask because 'it can't help me'.

Further, just yesterday on HN, there was a post about how a University study of airplane travelers showed mask-wearers got both benefits - they rarely caught anything and rarely infected anyone, even with the simplest masks.

[anon102010]

False - hand to nose mouth contact is THE primary vector for this illness - masks are very effective in reducing this. Please stop spreading misinformation as it could lead to deaths.

[lecanucker]

> hand to nose mouth contact is THE primary vector for this illness

Do you have a source for this? It's contrary to most of what I've read (droplets through air is primary vector).

[anon102010]

Droplets through the air is not primary vector - this is not aerosolized well like measels, the drops fall to the ground -> 6 foot rule is designed to avoid most droplets.

"In an adjusted analysis of compliant subjects, masks as a group had protective efficacy in excess of 80% against clinical influenza-like illness." -https://www.ijidonline.com/article/S1201-9712(08)01008-4/ful...

All the folks saying masks don't work literally never cite to any actual study - I think it's something like 90+ studies showing masks work and maybe 1 or 2 without a good result for masks.

[lecanucker]

I'm curious where you get the assertion that

> Droplets through the air is not primary vector

and

> hand to nose mouth contact is THE primary vector for this illness

In contrast, Johns Hopkins guide currently states: "Transmission - By respiratory droplets and by fomite. Virus found in respiratory secretions and saliva. - Viral shedding by asymptomatic people described, uncertain to what degree this occurs and abets transmission. - Stool shedding also described, but uncertain what role, if any, that plays." https://www.hopkinsguides.com/hopkins/view/Johns_Hopkins_ABX...

[stronglikedan]

I'm not spreading misinformation. Most people don't bother to wear the masks correctly, and they provide a false sense of security and overconfidence.

[analog31]

Is the overconfidence documented anywhere, in terms of its effect? Is the problem avoided by having a reasonable sense of security?

[spoovy]

I'd disagree with the false sense of security line. Why would someone who cares enough to go to the effort of wearing a mask then go and not wash their hands? A positive correlation between the two seems more likely than negative to me. Also this argument is trotted out regularly by "experts" in the car manufacturing industry whenever new safety technology is invented and as far as I can tell is always proven years later to be bullshit. For examples see seat belts, air bags, traction control, ABS, AWD.