[lkirk]

In my experience, there's a balance to be stricken. I really like notebooks for documenting the algorithm development process. I used to do a ton of repl driven development and Jupyter is a repl that allows you to persist commands across sessions. It saves a ton of time that I used to spend scrolling through the ipython history after closing and restarting the session. Jupyter also allows you to manage different kernels in the same environment, so it makes tasks like testing code between py2 and py3 trivial. My final point here is that there's also excellent cython integration, so you can do a lot of prototyping of cython code without having to mess with configuration or multiple files. I will agree that there are tasks better suited to IDEs, but jupyter is not just a plotting frontend, it can be used very effectively in algorithm development and the communication/documentation of the development thought process.

Typically, I have a git repo with the final code products, some of the more complex code gets written in notebooks, then transferred to git and thoroughly tested. I've been dreaming of this debugging experience in jupyter because that's still not a task that's suitable for notebooks, but I am hoping that it will come for vanilla python kernels before I can hope to adopt it.