[pliu]

In cases like the example mentioned, this is clearly a malicious entity. I don't agree that "get a subpoena" is the right response, some judgement should be applied to cases where someone is clearly using your service to do harm.

[AnthonyMouse]

I'm pretty happy with "judgement" being a thing that courts do and not a thing unqualified call center drones do.

[jacurtis]

> some judgement should be applied to cases where someone is clearly using your service to do harm

This is Facebook's argument essentially. But who decides that it is "clearly" doing harm? Should Facebook have the power to just tear domains away from their owners at their sole discretion? Should Namecheap be deciding if they break their privacy contract (the entire WHOISGUARD product that they offer) because a domain sounds too close to another company's product? Why should Facebook (or Namecheap) have the power to soley make decisions on this manner? Why do they get to "play god"?

These types of Copyright or Trademark issues have a proper and appropriate channel for handling these disputes. Facebook should be using the APPROPRIATE channels (ie the Judicial system) to handle this. The courts could issue a subpoena to Namecheap and Namecheap can take it down or hand over the information or whatever a judge decides should be done. But a sworn judge is the one that should be making these decisions, not a private company. This is where Namecheap is right in its stance and Facebook is wrong. Facebook is big and has lots of money, but that doesn't allow them to circumvent the Justice system. We swear in Judges to handle things like this. The judge can decide if this is "clearly" a violation or not. The judge will also help decide on the gray cases as well. The Judge will look at the facts of each case individually and help to protect Facebook's copyrights and trademarks while also protecting the rights of the citizen that owns the domain in question. He is the impartial authority that is trained and authorized to make these decisions.

Namecheap is doing it right, and this makes me very happy to be registering domains through them. I am happy that they don't buckle to the pressure of a big scary corporation. Facebook is once again proving that they are not a good internet citizen. Another reason the world would be better if they disappeared. Facebook isn't above the rest of us, or our governmental processes. The fact that they think they are is reason enough to never trust them with your data.

[mundo]

And in cases that aren't so clear? One of the three cited in the press release was instagrambusinesshelp.com - that doesn't sound remotely malicious to me.

[lima]

Still a likely trademark violation. But yes, not something Namecheap should decide.