Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mindslight 2306 days ago
Housing is overpriced because anyone can go to a bank and get as much cash as the house is appraised for, which is circular. So the actual constraint is just the inverse of interest rates. The same goes for education. There are underlying supply problems with each of these that need to be directly addressed, but they're exacerbated by the current economic policy of giving out as much rope needed to hang one's self.

I think much of healthcare could be solved if providers had to publish uniform prices and couldn't post-facto bill, you know, like every other business. Imagine going to the grocery store, paying at the register, and then two months later receiving a bill in the mail for the cashier's time!

Still, I am not opposed to single payer as a way forward - assuming it doesn't get transmuted into mandatory patronage of the same corrupt system. It's not like Medicare currently solves the underlying issues, it just absorbs the cost disease.

Basic income is a natural extension of quantitative easing. It will help people in rural areas, but do nothing for in-demand areas (being swallowed up by housing). I do agree it's much better than just giving the money to the banks though!

Direct infrastructure improvement - party on! Government "public works" is currently focused on the military, producing a surplus of chaos and misery abroad, while our infrastructure crumbles. I don't know that subsidizing suburban infrastructure fully makes sense, but I do know it's better than squandering the resources elsewhere.

1 comments

> Housing is overpriced because anyone can go to a bank and get as much cash as the house is appraised for, which is circular.

The appraised value is just a signal how much collateral a bank can rely on for the loan, which is why most loans with good interest rates have a maximum loan to value ratio. Banks don't want to own houses, they want to own a piece of the borrower's future productivity, manifested as interest payments.

The limited housing/transit supply (due to zoning restrictions) coupled with concentrated job growth are what drives up housing costs.

I did go on to acknowledge the "underlying supply problem". But this thread is about financials, and without the endless supply of money, asset valuations would be much lower.