[Latty]

It definitely depends on context.

There are some cases where opinionated is just fundamentally better. I'd say that a good example of this is code formatting tools. These have been historically highly configurable, but that creates huge amounts of room for bikeshedding and conflict, where consistency is by far the most important thing and the actual style itself barely matters unless you start getting silly.

I think it essentially becomes a sliding scale on how much consistency and "getting it right" are more important over having something be optimal or perfectly adapted to the situation.

When it comes to security tools like VPNs, reducing the chances for users to shoot themselves in the foot is almost always more important than anything else, so it seems like another area that would be beneficial to have something more opinionated rather than more configurable, so the decisions are in the hands of people who have invested the time in understanding the problems at hand.