Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by altmind 2305 days ago
What are the options to have windows domain controller? We got some 20-30 windows7 and 10 pcs and need to centrally manage them - with profile roaming, with SMB ACL, and Administrative policies.

With this strong push towards Azure, there is still no replacement for AD, neither samba reached the point of being a primary controller replacement. Are active directory domain services supposed to be an alternative? It seems to me they only provide ldaps and able to login on windows, but no trusts and nothing to enable sharing ACLs.

So for a new deployment, with ample time to learn the options, I still have to setup some redundant windows servers, with AD and trusts, the old way.

1 comments

If you're already using Azure, then Azure AD might be an option to look into if you're not wanting to run your own Domain Controllers. Otherwise, you can continue running them just as you've been able to for the last 20 years.

Retiring these certifications has exactly zero to do with any Active Directory or Domain Controller functionality.

(To me, yours seems a bit of an odd question, so I apologize if I'm maybe missing something in your question.)