Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Mirioron 2313 days ago
I'm curious: what do you think about the police in the UK going after people that post mean tweets on Twitter? Does it erode your faith in the police even further?
2 comments

Honestly, twitter and the social media outlets should be on top of that and whilst many think it's a waste of time for the police to be doing that, they need to remember that there are laws pertaining to communications that equally apply to later technology and should be applied.

So I'm just fine with them doing it and if anything, you could say they are a bit soft upon that front.

I'd add that until these twitter crimes see twitter pay a fine for each instance, they will carry on. Sure it won't be fair, but the unfairness has been one-sided too long and not just twitter - all social media platforms.

[EDIT ADD reference to pertaining communications act] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Act_2003

This superceeded the 1984 laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_1984

But they both cover communications that will cause offence.

What has changed perhaps is what people define as offencive. Now that is a matter of debate that will go on for ages, but I don't hold any disdain for the police in that respect, not do I have any experience upon that matter to draw upon.

That's really interesting to know. Thank you for your perspective!
It doesn't happen much. Almost all those things you hear about are either campaigns of harassment or incitement to violence.

Sometimes, rarely, it's the police having a discussion to let someone know what the law is in order to prevent that person committing an offence. And even this discussion with potential offenders is probably going to end after the police mishandling of the Henry Miller case: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/miller-v...

How do you feel about US police arresting six year old children for misbehaviour in class? https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-us-canada-51638871/six-y...

>Almost all those things you hear about are either campaigns of harassment or incitement to violence.

I rarely hear about those. Almost all of the cases that make international news are about police "checking someone's thinking" or arresting someone for posting lyrics or satire.

>How do you feel about US police arresting six year old children for misbehaviour in class?

Sounds exactly like something I'd expect from the US. Over policing is a problem that have over there. I was asking the parent poster about this specific point, because they were disappointed with how the police use their resources. I was curious how they felt about police resources being used to deal with tweets instead of something else. Personally it would annoy the hell out of me if the police weren't doing their jobs actually doing police work, but somehow still found the resources to police mean tweets. Those priorities seem backwards to me.