Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ceejayoz 5602 days ago
Is it possible that German businesses do the smart thing and don't require a bachelor's degree for basic data entry and other similar tasks?

I have a hard time believing 55% of the jobs in the US require a college education to perform.

2 comments

Yes, that is correct. Obviously, with rising numbers of University graduates the situation is beginning to change -- albeit at a much slower rate than in the US. There are plenty professions that do not require a BA.[2]

I agree with the sentiment, by the way. University access in this sense[1] isn't intrinsically desirable. Quite the opposite. For a large chunk of professions, higher education is in fact a waste of money and incurs significant opportunity/real costs for the student. (Data entry with 150,000$ debt in addition to losing out on a similar amount of salary?) It's nice that a degree mill like the University of Phoenix has more students than half of Germany, but I don't understand why that's necessarily a strength. A significant proportion (> 60%?) will regret that degree.

[1] There are two interpretations of the notion. First, you want everybody's chances to be equal. That is, no racial or social discrimination when it comes to HE access. Second, you want everybody to go to university. That seems highly, highly inefficient. (Not all people require HE, even if you consider education an intrinsic good. Non-broken high school education help.) [2] It's important to acknowledge the cultural differences here: BAs (i.e., limited primary college degrees) were introduced very recently. Up until 2004-2005, you'd always graduate with Diplom or Magister which go a lot further than US BAs.

Some people believe education has intrinsic value.
Some people believe an XBox has intrinsic value.

And much like the people who believe education has intrinsic value, they should pay for it themselves.

In the US, most people pay for education with private money.
Sure a real liberal arts education where you study the classics has intrinsic value.

Job tech training not so much.

Certainly, but I very much doubt 55% of America is paying tens of thousands of dollars for that reason.