Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by t0astbread 2311 days ago
Right. But you can't build a functioning team that works together and can rely on each other by fostering a culture of competition and hiring only the "predestined" 10x engineers.

If the team culture is to help each other, forgive mistakes and learn from each other without measuring who's the best the team will automatically build itself without the need to hire only "10x engineers".

Or so I suppose. I'm not an HR person or anyone else with expertise in this field so you should take what I say with a grain of salt. I've just been thinking about this a lot as of late.
2 comments
closeparen 2311 days ago
Where I’ve seen teams with high concentrations of unusually smart people, they gelled and collaborated at least as well as anyone else. In fact the bandwidth and fidelity of their idea transfers is part of what made them impressive. It’s like they had their own little language to describe the codebase and what to do with it.

These were mature and soft-spoken people; might be different with brash young hotshots.

link
t0astbread 2310 days ago
To me that sounds like an environment where there's not a lot of competition involved. (Which is what I was describing.)
link
closeparen 2310 days ago
They were far and away the most selective team in the company.

I’ve seen this before in university too; competitive to get into can still be cooperative once in.

link
t0astbread 2309 days ago
HN thread limit might cut this off but what if someone in that team starts experiencing problems and self-doubt? If everything in the team has always worked smoothly before they might not be able to handle it.

Additionally, elitist teams might scare off some people that could otherwise be great engineers if they just got a little entry help. Sure they can "get that elsewhere" but if every team behaved like that there's not only nowhere to enter, but there's also sort of an omnipresent assumption that you have to be good from the start in order to be able to achieve something in engineering.

I'm not saying your described team doesn't work but it's not exactly the kind of culture HR should be striving for in my opinion. (Albeit it's still far better than than a team that doesn't work at all or works against each other.)

link
lonelappde 2311 days ago
Your dream team is great, missing only a 10x person to lead them, inventing MapReduce or MacOS or AWS.
link