Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cosmic_ape 2325 days ago
Some comments seem to miss the point that reviews will be published without naming the reviewers (unless they want to), and then only for accepted papers. So for the reviewer this should not change things much.

Also, NeurIPS conference publishes reviews for a long time now. But I haven't heard of anyone talking about a review of a paper. And if you do look at these reviews, really many of them are of really dismal quality. Maybe things will be different for Nature, idk.
1 comments
captain_price7 2325 days ago
Do you know any other ML conference/journal, doesn't have to be NeurIPS quality,that also publishes reviews? I know there is ICLR, but anything else? I really like reading them.
link
cosmic_ape 2325 days ago
Not that I know of. But its seems a few other conferences use OpenReview, besides ICLR. UAI for example.
link