Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by VengefulCynic 2322 days ago
As an Iowan who has had the dubious pleasure of having used Shadow's software, I would like a lot of scrutiny directed at both Shadow and their software.

I worked as a Precinct Captain for one of the Caucuses in Iowa last night, and I didn't personally have any issues. But I heard from colleagues who definitely did. Also, yesterday we got an email with a 7-page google doc instructing us on how to reset the browser caches on our phones to avoid issues with data carry-over from the Mock Caucuses that we had been holding.

It's entirely possible that my ability to follow directions and my status as Not-an-Octegenarian-Caucus-Volunteer is all that kept me out of trouble.

As a software guy, all I can say for sure is that I'm overwhelmingly grateful that we kept paper backups so we don't have to rely on this software.

4 comments

All software involved in the voting process should (1) not exist except for tallying and communication purposes (no electronic voter records) and (2) be open sourced and verified by known third parties.

Four days ago when the register dug into this they were refused access to test the app[1], they were not given mockups or any information about the UI[1], they weren't told who developed the app[1], they weren't told how the contract was given out to develop the app[1], they weren't told why the app was thought to be necessary[1], and they were told the app was verified by a third party testing firm but that who that was couldn't be disclosed[1].

Iowa moving forward with this app was extremely ill-advised and I'm actually rather sad that the register didn't raise more hell on receiving all these red flags.

1. A red flag...

security by obscurity is not security.
It's entirely possible that my ability to follow directions and my status as Not-an-Octegenarian-Caucus-Volunteer is all that kept me out of trouble.

This is most likely the case. This is very much an issue in my day to day with applications like SAP CRM, some people get it, some people learn it, some never get it.

Can you share screenshots or at least tell us what the hard parts might have been?
Dude... That's a frickin' truism of my career and industry! :D

"As a [computer/sw/hw] guy, all I can say for sure is that I'm overwhelmingly grateful that we kept paper backups."