[SketchySeaBeast]

So if we do end up in the same place, then "Sheriffs being elected is actually extremely important." is still false.

I'm not saying that either system is perfect, but it seems to me the idea that somehow being elected makes a sheriff better is outright false.

[cortesoft]

Fair enough, although there might be SOME benefit to having separate election systems for the two roles; it might provide some check against one of the election systems being compromised.