Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by xenospn 2339 days ago
So I'm supposed to leave the toothpaste in my mouth? For how long?

EDIT: I'd also like to point out that I have been rinsing my mouth after brushing for the last 40 years, never used mouthwash, and never had a cavity.

4 comments

You may have higher levels of calcium in your saliva than normal. I know someone who has poor dental hygiene practices and never had a cavity, partly due to excess calcium. Instead of cavities, he has problems with calcium deposits accumulating in his plaque.

My point is, you may simply be an outlier rather a meaningful counter example.

I'm not sure if this is correct but when I was in college I noticed a couple guys who just spit and didn't rinse at all. Like, ever. They just brush, spit out some toothpaste, and then move on to the next step of their routine.

At the time it seemed kinda freaky to me since I always rinse the toothpaste out when I finish brushing, but maybe they were doing it right... I can't get over the feeling over toothpaste stuck in my mouth, though. Perhaps it's one of those things that's hard to change once you establish a pattern in childhood.

Hah. This is perfectly normal for me. I have never done the rinsing after toothbrushing thing. There's definitely something about childhood patterns though. The slight taste of toothpaste in my mouth makes me feel clean and refreshed. I brush my teeth several times a day, usually just before I go somewhere.
So you just walk away from the sink and let a poisonous substance sit in your mouth while you slowly but surely swallow it all?
I never thought about it that way, but I guess so. Sometimes I even have a sip of water if it is too toothpasty.
If it kills the bacteria on your mouth that’s got to hurt your gut too.
It's not about killing bacteria, its about leaving fluoride ions in a slightly basic or at least nonacidic environment for long enough to convert hydroxyapatite to fluorohydroxyapatite. This chemical reaction takes time, but considerably strengthens your teeth against corrosion and prevents cavities.
Brushing is mainly supposed to mechanically take the bacteria off of your teeth, like washing your hands, not kill them chemically. The fluoride exists to help keep enamel intact.
You can spit but don't add water. That should get rid of most of it.
Right but the question is for how long? Surely you're not supposed to never put water in your mouth again, so how long should you wait? 1 minute? 10 minutes? An hour?
30 minutes according to some dentists I know.

I used to rinse my mouth with water, now I just spit the toothpaste.

I haven't asked but this may be recommended only if you're not using an abrasive toothpaste which could damage your teeth enamel.

Depends what you're optimizing for. If you never eat or drink anything again, your teeth will stay healthy until you die...?

I've heard dentists recommend brushing after every meal. Which really doesn't seem realistic for people who snack or regularly drink coffee / tea.

Have you ever brushed your teeth?? (Just joking)
I think we all use excessive amount of toothpaste. That makes us get a mouth full of foam, that subsequently forces us to rinse instead of just spit.
Great marketing by Colgate. They just show the toothpaste covering the entire length of the brush and we all follow along.
I just got a very short brush.
“Don't rinse your mouth immediately after brushing, as it'll wash away the concentrated fluoride in the remaining toothpaste”

Sorry but that’s unacceptable to me. Come up with a better way for me to clean my teeth or I’ll keep rinsing immediately.

I do actually do this with fluoride and alcohol free mouthwash though. That’s easier to not rinse for 30 minutes.

Well, the free advice and the rationale behind it has been given. Now you can do what you want with it. They're your teeth, after all.