Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by posix_me_less 2343 days ago
Loss of power during distribution is not a problem that needs solving, power losses due to transmission in conventional grid are mere 5%.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_power_transmission#Lo...

Considering how costly and inflexible all superconductors are, I don't see why they would help.

1 comments

Those losses are on a per 100 mile basis. 2-5% per 100 miles of line (not as the crow flies mind you). Superconductors would make a huge difference if they could build a room temperature superconductor.
Exactly, when people mention losses saved by superconductors they don't mean to improve the current grid. It's to route power from the always sunny side of the planet.
HVDC is already below 3% per 1'000km. So connecting Europe to the Sahara is around 5% with current technology
No. Sorry the Mediterranean Sea separates Europe from Sahara (as well as several countries) and you can't do this practically by any means. Europe doesn't own the Sahara.
The main problem with installing solar in the Sahara and transporting it to Europe is the political instability of the region. Laying cables across a sea or ocean is already routinely done.
There's communication cables laid across the sea. There's no examples I know of High Voltage transmission with enough power to operate Europe. It's not only the instability of Sahara, but laying a cable across the sea for the transmission of enough energy to power Europe would require defense of the cables. A submarine could otherwise attack the grid and take Europe offline. This is unpractical on a lot of levels and hand-waving this as a reasonable solution is silly.
You're kind of getting at my point, at 0 resistance you can route around any of these problems. A planet wide mesh is just logistics at that point.
We all manage with oil. The key has to be getting the resource without making the region worse, which hasn’t been the case with oil.
The 5% is quoted further in the article for overall grid waste. The per mile basis is purely there to compare why higher voltages for the Samer power lead to less waste.