Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by neap24 2342 days ago
This reminds me of a lesson I learned in an intro to Economics class : everyone's lot in life is a combination of luck, effort, and ability. Those whose view of the world from a left-of-center perspective (those who downplay self-reliance) really just think luck far outweighs the other two. Someone right-of-center thinks that effort is the most important. Most right-of-center people I know don't discredit the impact of other people on their lives. They just live as if effort and self-reliance can help them overcome bad luck.
2 comments

If by right of center you mean Republicans and not say Chinese or Japanese, who also fit the bill.

(All of which are just as conservative. Chinese believe in circumstance, Japanese believe in maximum effort in current circumstance with a few key choices, Republicans believe any decision is mostly on the individual.)

It's never an absolute, but there is a big difference between living as if effort is a major thing that matters and believing it is the only thing that matters or more important than the other two.

Former can get you to push harder, latter brings nothing good - it is a problem because it brings pathologies especially blame, false hope and exploitation.

Ultimately there are only a few impactful things most of us can control. Therefore these things are important.

These are key decisions and it is rather hard to change them. The unfortunate fact is that we get to make them too early when we're inexperienced and some are still dumb. And you get few or no retries. (High school, college, these impact where you live, with whom, your late life social circles, even health.)

Whether you become bitter because of this is up to you.

I figure a lot of folks are angry at the broad generalization you've stated, but I can corroborate it a bit with statistics. Conscientiousness broadly correlates with affiliation with right-wing parties. This personality trait would trend towards admiration for self-reliance (by my figuring).

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01918...

I've linked 1 study above but there are many more studies with the same conclusion. I also think that your generalization makes obvious sense, even without having to rely on statistics.